At this past Sunday’s Earth Day service, Rev. Taryn spent some time in her sermon talking about Georgia’s Public Service Commission (see it here). Is this five-person elected body doing holy work somehow? No, far from it, but their decisions about how Georgia Power generates electricity and holds ratepayers responsible demand that our congregation get into some “good trouble.” She highlighted the current deliberations around the Integrated Resource Plan as a key moment to activate and advocate. Feeling a little out of the loop? Here are answers to common questions gleaned from training resources shared by Georgia Interfaith Power & Light and Southface Institute (several members of the Climate Action Team attended these sessions). What is the Integrated Resource Plan?A utility IRP is a long-term plan and planning process where a utility estimates long-term demand and provides a plan for meeting that forecasted demand reliably and cost-effectively. A utility IRP typically considers anticipated customer expansion, economic growth, unit retirements, demand-side management, environmental regulations, required reserve margin, transmission capacity and constraints, etc. In Georgia, state law requires all electrical utilities (i.e., Georgia Power) to submit an IRP every three years, and the Georgia Public Service Commission presides over a detailed review of the utility’s proposed IRP. According to the Sierra Club, this year's IRP "calls for delaying planned retirements of coal burning power plants, increasing the use of so-called 'natural gas' or methane gas as a fuel, and does not make any meaningful attempt to add more renewable energy to our grid. For context, Georgia Power’s energy mix in 2023 was made up of 46% gas/oil, 25% nuclear, 16% coal, 7% renewables."Why is the Public Service Commission involved?Public Service Commission is a typical title for state commissions that regulate investor-owned electricity, natural gas, water, telecom, railroad, and/or public livery/transportation services. Public service commissioners are elected in 10 states and appointed in the other 40. Our PSC has been steeped in election controversy. A year ago, the Saporta Report reported on a lawsuit brought by Georgia WAND and Georgia Conservation Voters that alleged that “Georgia violated state constitution with HB-1312, which unilaterally blocked public service commissioner elections and allowed sitting members to rubberstamp controversial utility bill hikes, the highest in state history.” Georgia is holding a special election for two of five seats on the Georgia Public Service Commission on November 4. The primary is June 17 – only six weeks away!How involved is this plan?The 2025 IRP filing contains approximately 31 documents, consisting of 1,669 pages, and 15 spreadsheets containing 90 worksheets (not including procedural documents such as transmittal letters, certificates of service, folder indexes and cover pages). Use this table of contents to see how the filing is organized.What is special about the “rate case”?Typically after an IRP, Georgia Power will file a “rate case” with the Public Service Commission so that it can change electricity rates and bills. Like the IRP, the rate case requires a litigated quasi-judicial proceeding with a series of hearings. While an IRP seeks to answer the questions, “How much electricity do we need and how will we generate and provide it?” a rate case asks, “Okay, now how will we pay for it?”According to the Southern Environmental Law Center, “The Georgia Public Service Commission has approved six increases to Georgia Power customers’ bills since 2023. There are many reasons for the increases, including passing onto customers the costs of coal and methane gas (a fossil fuel with a steep and often unstable pricetag) and the steep bills to fund the Plant Vogtle nuclear generating units, which were exorbitantly over budget.”Is the PSC doing a good job of looking out for ratepayers?First, a little history. According to the Southern Alliance for Clean Energy: “When Investor-Owned Utilities (IOUs) were being established in the early 20th century, lawmakers wanted to provide oversight in exchange for granting utilities their monopoly status. As monopolies, IOUs would not be subject to normal market competition, and decision-makers recognized that this could be a problem. Since customers could not choose to buy electricity from anyone else within the monopoly territory, public utility commissions (in Georgia, the Public Service Commission) were created to balance the utilities’ need for profit (without which they would have no motive to pay upfront to build the electric grid) with customers’ interests. In theory, this system would ensure that utility companies didn’t exploit this monopoly status and pass exorbitant costs on to customers. Unfortunately, over the years, many commissions have tended to side with utility companies over the interests of customers. Instead of protecting customers from unnecessarily high bills, many PUCs allow utilities to invest with abandon, driving up share prices and guaranteed profits, while customers shoulder the increased costs resulting from those investments.”Uh-oh. What else? Like other IOUs, Georgia Power heavily lobbies policy makers and often opposes state and federal policy that would promote renewables or hold the company to a higher account than the PSC has been willing to do, the Alliance explains. Georgia Power’s profits rose in 2024 as Plant Vogtle (left) came online and customers began to pay for the additional cost. After charging customers, on average, $926 over 14 years to build Plant Vogtle, Georgia Power began raising rates again starting last May to cover the costs – and cost-overruns – of the new nuclear units.A year ago, the PSC approved Georgia Power’s plan to build three new gas and oil combustion units, whose cost will be recovered through rate increases for decades to come. In addition to increasing customer rates, this will also increase our reliance on fossil gas, leaving customers exposed to fuel cost volatility. Fossil gas prices increase and decrease due to a host of factors. If (and when) the price of fossil gas rises, as it has in the past, the utility will be allowed to seek more fuel cost recovery in the form of increased customer bills. According to the Alliance, Georgia Power often eschews investments in lower-cost energy efficiency and opposes policies that would promote on-site and distributed generation solar (such as net metering and community solar), which could save ratepayers money and limit the need for additional new fossil power plants. The Sierra Club provided three takeaways from the first round of IRP hearings held in March. First, "Georgia Power’s own analysts confirm most of the electricity demand is still being driven by data centers." Next, "Georgia Power doesn’t care that they are killing the climate goals of its large load customers (or their own)." Finally, "Georgia Power has a massive expansion of methane gas planned, but doesn’t want to talk about it." During the May 27-30 hearings, the PSC will hear from commission staff and those that have intervened in the process, including the Sierra Club. The organization expects "both staff and interveners will push back against Georgia Power’s plans to keep coal online for longer, challenge the electricity demand projections in the utility’s proposal, and attempt to find out more about gas turbines proposed for Plant Bowen." What are “intervenors”? Who has stepped up this year?Intervenors are formal parties in a PSC case who have a direct and substantial interest in the outcome. Unlike public commenters or interested persons, intervenors play an active role in the legal proceedings. They can file testimony and present evidence to support their positions, request information from Georgia Power, cross-examine witnesses presented by other parties, submit legal briefs summarizing their arguments, and attend all hearings. You probably recognize the names of some of this year’s intervenors: GIPL, Georgia WAND, Sierra Club, Southern Alliance for Clean Energy, Southern Environmental Law Center, and Southface. How can we make our voices heard?Community members can make public comments in several ways. First, the Georgia PSC maintains an online comment page where people can make written comments. Second, Georgia PSC allows oral public comment at committee meetings that happen every two weeks in the PSC hearing room. Finally, the Georgia PSC allows for oral public comments in the hearing room for some period of time at the beginning of each hearing day. You can also find more info about public comment opportunities on the IRP page developed by Southern Environmental Law Center. Regular PSC meetings are held in-person at the Commission in downtown Atlanta on alternating Tuesdays and Thursdays at 9:30 AM, with periodic exceptions. Thursday committee hearings involve discussion, including staff recommendations, on an agenda that must be made available before the hearing. Votes on issues are held during Tuesday administrative sessions. Public comment opportunities are available on Thursday committee hearing days, but not Tuesday administrative sessions. Comments are heard during the last 15 minutes of committee meetings. Speakers should see the Executive Secretary for the sign-up sheet, which is provided one hour prior to the start of the meeting. In addition to providing public comment during regular PSC meetings, members of the public may provide comments during litigated proceedings, during the first hour (9:30-10:30 AM) of a hearing day. You can share your comments online, and here’s an easy guide. Be sure to enter the docket number that your comment pertains to so that the comment will be filed accurately in the public record. If you want to attend in person, all PSC meetings and hearings are held in room 110, 244 Washington Street, Atlanta, GA 30334. Can’t make it downtown? No worries. Meetings are live-streamed on YouTube here.Does our participation matter?Let’s hear it from the horse’s mouth – errr, the PSC itself: “‘My fellow Commissioners and I make every effort to hear from Georgian’s during the IRP process,’ said PSC Chairman Jason Shaw. ‘As we weigh evidence presented to us by expert witnesses, engineers and energy analysts, we also read all comments sent by the public and listen to every public witness who takes the time to speak at the hearings. It is a vitally important part of the IRP process.’ Now that the IRP has been filed, the PSC’s Public Interest Advocacy Staff will utilize experts in finance and energy production to analyze Georgia Power’s plan. The IRP will be litigated over the next six months where PSC staff request data from Georgia Power, expert witnesses file testimony, and the Commissioners will hold the hearing that will include witnesses and cross examination. As many as two dozen outside intervenors will join the process and are likewise able to file documents, present witnesses and cross-examine other witnesses. On July 15, at the PSC’s regularly scheduled Administrative Session, the Commissioners will vote on the final version of the Georgia Power IRP, including all changes made during the process.”Who’s leading the charge?Rev. Ranwa Hammamy, the Congregational Justice Organizer with UUA’s Side with Love Organizing Strategy Team, and Josie Mitz, UU the Vote Strategy Support, are working closely with the UU Georgia Legislative Action Network to activate our state’s UU congregations over these important next few months. UUCA’s own Jane Nelson and Joy Borra are helping organize. The Climate Action Team relies on advocacy cues from Marqus Cole, Organizing Director at our partner Georgia Interfaith Power & Light. Take a moment to add your name to GIPL’s petition to the PSC that calls for clean, affordable energy that prioritizes people over corporate profit. Expect to hear more about how you can speak up for a focus on energy equity, a move to renewable sources, and a PSC that represents the planet's best interests. • • • JOIN US: Whatever your schedule, whatever your passion: the Climate Action Team wants YOU as a member! Learn about our initiatives here and check out our minutes and take action table, our lending library, and the Carbon Offset Fund. You can also request to join the Climate Action Team on Realm. Email climateaction@uuca.org to connect to the CAT. We meet next on Monday, May 19, at 7:30 PM using this Zoom link, and we would love to see you!